Free U.S. seed shipping $25+. Seeds ship free at the threshold. Storefront goods, pantry finds, books & local goods are being added.

New seeds, Main Street specials, and storefront finds update as the market grows.

← Back to Growing Guides & Planting Advice

Variety chooser and comparison guide

What to Plant Now

Types of Lettuce: Looseleaf, Butterhead, Romaine, Crisphead & More

Choose lettuce by texture, head form, heat tolerance, harvest rhythm, and the way the crop will be used in the kitchen.

Buttercrunch butterhead lettuce forming a compact green head
In this article

    Quick answer

    Choose lettuce by head form, heat response, and harvest style

    Looseleaf lettuce is harvested leaf by leaf or as a cut-and-come-again crop. Butterhead forms soft heads. Romaine forms upright hearts. Crisphead needs a longer cool season and careful timing. Summer-crisp types bridge some of the gap between leaf and head lettuce.

    Lettuce forms at a glance

    Type Form Best harvest style
    Looseleaf Open rosette Baby leaf and repeated cutting
    Butterhead Soft head Whole heads and tender leaves
    Romaine Upright head Hearts and mature heads
    Crisphead Dense round head Cool-season whole heads
    Summer crisp Loose-to-dense head Warm-season transition

    Choose lettuce by texture, head form, heat tolerance, harvest rhythm, and the way the crop will be used in the kitchen.

    Seedkeeper's field record
    Good seed begins the work. Good observation finishes it.
    Scientific nameLactuca sativa
    Crop identityLooseleaf, butterhead, romaine, summer crisp, and crisphead lettuce
    Botanical familyAsteraceae
    Life cycleAnnual
    Primary useBaby leaf, cut-and-come-again harvest, compact heads, salads, wraps, and cooking greens
    Seed-saving systemPrimarily self-pollinating; collect mature seed heads repeatedly
    Provenance statusCrop comparison guide; variety histories kept separate
    Regional fitCool-season crop throughout the United States; fall and winter culture is valuable in mild climates
    Buttercrunch butterhead lettuce forming a compact green head
    Butterhead lettuce forms a soft, folded head with tender leaves and a mild flavor.

    Choose leaf, butterhead, romaine, crisphead, or summer-crisp lettuce

    Looseleaf, butterhead, romaine, summer crisp, and crisphead lettuce should be chosen by season, space, and kitchen use, not by a photograph alone. One gardener needs a fast spring crop; another needs a fall harvest that can stand through cold. A market grower values uniformity and bunching. A seedkeeper also asks how many plants can be maintained when flowering begins.

    Use cool germination and succession sowing to avoid bolting

    Cool-season crop throughout the United States; fall and winter culture is valuable in mild climates. Cool-season crops can survive cold that would stop a tomato, yet they lose quality when roots stall in saturated soil or when heads form under sustained heat. Count backward from the weather you want at harvest, not forward from the day you happen to feel ready.

    Black Seeded Simpson looseleaf lettuce with frilled green leaves
    Looseleaf lettuce stays open rather than forming a head and can be harvested one leaf at a time.
    Forellenschluss romaine lettuce with upright speckled leaves
    Forellenschluss is an upright romaine with red-speckled leaves and a crisp central rib.
    Jericho romaine lettuce forming a tall upright head
    Jericho romaine forms a tall head and is known for maintaining quality in warmer conditions.

    Harvest baby leaf, outer leaves, or whole heads deliberately

    Baby leaf, cut-and-come-again harvest, compact heads, salads, wraps, and cooking greens. Quality is often a narrow gate. Lettuce turns bitter, radish becomes woody, broccoli loosens into flower, cabbage splits, and spinach bolts. Harvest is not the reward after the work; it is part of the work.

    Leave selected lettuce plants through flowering and seed maturity

    Primarily self-pollinating; collect mature seed heads repeatedly. A food crop can be harvested at its best eating stage. A seed crop must be carried through flowering, pollination, and full maturity. That takes more space, more time, and a willingness to leave the finest plants standing.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the biggest mistake with types of lettuce?
    Can I grow this crop in containers?
    Why did the crop become bitter, tough, or loose?
    Can I save seed from one plant?
    Should I trust the days-to-maturity number exactly?

    For more information and guidance

    Lettuce form changes the whole harvest plan

    Loose-leaf lettuce can be cut young, harvested leaf by leaf, or allowed to form a broad rosette. Butterhead makes a soft folded head. Romaine builds an upright ribbed head. Crisphead needs the longest cool period and the most exacting water management. Summer-crisp types bridge some of the gap by making substantial heads with better heat tolerance than traditional crisphead lettuce.

    The same variety can be managed as baby leaf or full-size lettuce, but the field plan is not the same. Baby leaf is sown densely and cut quickly. Full-size heads need individual spacing, root volume, and steady moisture. Pelleted seed can make precise spacing easier, but the coating must remain moist during germination.

    Bolting is a developmental response, not a moral failure

    Long days, high temperatures, root stress, and variety genetics all affect bolting. Shade cloth can buy time, but it cannot turn midsummer into spring. In hot climates, shift lettuce toward fall, winter, and early spring, use heat-tolerant types for transition periods, and harvest promptly before stems elongate and flavor changes.

    Germination and succession need different temperatures than mature plants

    Lettuce seed can germinate poorly in hot media even when established plants are still alive. Start late-summer sowings in a cooler location, use fresh seed, and move seedlings into the garden after emergence. Sow small batches at regular intervals instead of one oversized row; repeated modest harvests are usually more useful than a single week of surplus heads.

    For seed saving, leave selected plants through the tall flowering stage and protect mature seed heads from rain and shattering. Lettuce is mainly self-pollinated, but nearby varieties can still cross at low rates, so isolation remains part of honest variety maintenance.

    Selected next steps

    Butterhead Buttercrunch Lettuce featured in the Lettuce Seeds collection. Heirloom Lettuce Seeds for Home Gardens 25 options Ruby Red looseleaf lettuce representing the Looseleaf Lettuce Seeds collection. Looseleaf Lettuce Seeds 11 options Buttercrunch butterhead lettuce representing the Butterhead Lettuce Seeds collection. Butterhead Lettuce Seeds 5 options Parris Island Cos romaine lettuce representing the Romaine Lettuce Seeds collection. Romaine Lettuce Seeds 6 options

    Sources and further reading

    Evidence used in this article

    1. UMN Extension, Growing Lettuce